From Vision to Victory: How to craft a robust Business Case for Project success

The Importance of a robust Business Case in Project Management

In the world of project management, the business case is a critical document that lays the foundation for any successful project. However, there is a common tendency among organisations to inflate business cases to ensure they get approved. This practice often leads to underestimating the cost and time required to implement a project while overestimating the benefits.

One particular bugbear of mine is the inclusion of unrealisable savings to demonstrate an ROI. For example, upgrading an IT solution might save two minutes of time in logging onto a system each morning. When multiplied across thousands of staff at their normal charge-out rate, it looks attractive, but this time will never create more revenue nor result in real bottom-line savings.

The Role of a Robust Business Case

A robust business case is essential as part of a standardised methodology, which more mature organisations will have embedded within a Project Management Office (PMO). In these situations, the business case forms part of the Project Proposal, which is usually the second stage of a PMO process. The first stage is the ‘idea,’ which I like to conceptualise in a simple single-page Project Brief. This brief outlines the project concept, its intended purpose, benefits, and likely costs. It should also outline how it aligns with the organisation’s strategic objectives. The sole purpose of the Project Brief is to gain approval to spend time (and maybe modest cost) on the production of a detailed Proposal, which includes the Business Case.

Typical Content of a Project Proposal

A comprehensive Project Proposal typically includes the following sections:

1. Executive Summary: A brief overview of the project, its objectives, and the expected outcomes.
2. Project Background: Detailed information about the project’s origin, the problem it aims to solve, and its alignment with strategic goals.
3. Objectives and Scope: Clear and concise statements of the project’s objectives and the scope of work.
4. Benefits and Deliverables: A description of the expected benefits and the key deliverables of the project.
5. Cost and Resource Estimates: Detailed estimates of the project’s costs, including resources required.
6. Risk Analysis: Identification and analysis of potential risks and mitigation strategies.
7. Timeline and Milestones: A detailed project timeline with key milestones.
8. Stakeholder Analysis: Identification of key stakeholders and their roles in the project.
9. Conclusion: A summary of the proposal and a call to action for approval.

Avoiding Inflation in Business Cases

Inflating business cases can lead to unrealistic expectations and project failure. Here are some strategies to avoid this:

1. Realistic Cost Estimates: Ensure that cost estimates are based on thorough research and realistic assumptions. Avoid underestimating costs to make the project appear more attractive.
2. Accurate Benefit Projections: Be honest about the benefits the project will deliver. Avoid including unrealisable savings or benefits that cannot be measured.
3. Stakeholder Involvement: Involve key stakeholders in the development of the business case to ensure that all perspectives are considered and that the case is realistic.
4. Regular Reviews: Conduct regular reviews of the business case throughout the project to ensure that it remains accurate and relevant.
5. Use Templates and Guides: Utilise standardised templates and guides to ensure consistency and accuracy in business case development. Contact me if you would like some examples of business case and project proposal templates.

Benefits of Producing a Business Case

Producing a robust business case offers several benefits. It provides a clear understanding of the project’s purpose, benefits, and costs, helping stakeholders make informed decisions. It also mitigates the risk of project failure by ensuring that all aspects of the project are thoroughly analysed and planned. Additionally, the business case acts as a reference point throughout the early stages of implementation, helping to keep the project on track and within budget.

Conclusion

In conclusion, a robust business case is essential for any successful project. It serves as a firm foundation, mitigates risks, and provides a clear reference point throughout the project’s early stages. By adopting this approach, organisations can ensure that their projects are well-planned, realistic, and aligned with their strategic objectives.

---

Are you ready to take your project management to the next level? Start by crafting a solid business case that lays the foundation for success. Utilise the templates and guides available to ensure consistency and accuracy. Remember, a robust business case is the key to turning your vision into victory. Let’s make your next project a triumph!

Paul Every
Assurify Consulting, Jersey